Pomegranate saw his choices and took them as follows:
1. Do not comply with the wishes of the FBI. This will most likely lead to the seizure of flag and a compromise of all the sites and information online. It will probably also lead to me being imprisoned, I would guess. I personally do not fear this, but I am the sole support for my wife and infant daughter. There can be no doubt we would probably lose our home as a result.
2. Comply with the wishes of the FBI, provide the IP addresses, and count on the fact that I will catch a lot of heat and hatred from my comrades in the anarchist movement worldwide.
Though it pains me to comply with the State in any manner, I have to choose option #2. The people who have foolishly compromised us all will shoulder the burden for their selfish actions. Frankly folks, they know better - we all know better.
I have to admit to being disappointed. Maybe what’s even worse is the number of those clammering over themselves to comfort Pomegranate in his decision. Comfort, as it ever is for those of us in the West, appears to be the objective. What use is all this talking about a better world if we are not prepared to stand up for it with our lives? That we get to continue to bare perpetual “moral witness” to the world around us?
In any case, putting such criticism aside, and bearing in mind the stupidity (or spooks) that Pomegranate is now having to deal with, it seems to me the biggest lesson to come out of this mess is that IP logs shouldn’t have been kept in the first place.
Update: Pomegranate writes:
none of the information provided is from an http log. when you post to phpbb, mediawiki, geeklog etc. etc., your ip is recorded with your post. it’s not a log, it’s built into the software. admins can see it.
if you post here anonymously, i can still see the IP you used every time i read the message. it’s permanent and it’s not something i can change without changing to different software.



Recent Comments